North America Forum

 Forgot password?
 立即注册
Search

We are working to make our Terms of Service agreement easier to read in order to provide you with better services while protecting your personal data. We hope you can spare a few minutes to read the recently updated User Terms of Service. User Terms of Service Privacy Policy
View: 339| Reply: 3

Instant attack feature for rallies on players

[Copy link]

1

Threads

2

Posts

0

Credits

User

Rank: 1

Credits
0
Fooly Man
User
Posts:2
Joined 2019-11-17
Last Visited 2020-07-08
Post time 2020-2-28 22:29:43 | Show all posts |Read mode
Instant attack feature for rallies on players Reply:3| View:339
Hey,
I'm wondering if we could implement the 'instant attack' feature for rallies against other players' castles.  Right now it's only working for AC and rallies on rebel camps + dragons. I think this would add an interesting strategic layer that would help smaller alliances and players stand a chance against stronger players (+whales).  What do you all think?

Single Polls, Total 14 Users voted

Poll is finished

71.43% (10)
28.57% (4)
Your User group have no permission to vote

 Fooly Man Last edit in 2020-2-28 22:29:43

 Support

Report
Default Signature
Reply

Use magic Report

4

Threads

21

Posts

0

Credits

User

Rank: 1

Credits
0
howas1337
User
Posts:21
Joined 2019-11-26
Last Visited 2021-07-01
Post time 2020-2-29 04:26:03 | Show all posts
no that will kill the balance...
Translate
Floor reply (7)
  • my heavens, this is the 2nd post where your 'whale-type' selfishness just sickenly and selfishly SPEWS forth .. get a grip man, look at these things from the pov of the 100% playerbase, not just the monied selfish few who think they don't need to learn any lessons of humility and generosity .. good luck m8, yer gonna need it soon ..
    Translate
    2020-2-29 06:06  Reply
  • oh yes .. WHAT BALANCE ?????
    Translate
    2020-2-29 06:08  Reply
  • ye i am looking it from that viev, and u surly dont think sober, for start i am just 100m mostly f2p player... and if u make insta rallys , what will stop the whales to abuse it... they will bring few people or alts and atack you with 3m troops at a time, solo atacks will be stupid after ... think before posting...

    Translate
    2020-3-2 17:15  Reply
  • Sure, valid point. Let's go over a few scenarios.

    - Whale #1 comes in to start burning hives.
    - Whale #1 has 2-3 alts in order to increase rallies to 1mil  troops and insta-hit players

    Case 1:
    - anyone bubbled will not be affected. So this argument is null.

    Case 2:
    - those who are unbubbled and have less than 100m power (or doesn't have t4s yet) will most certainly get destroyed regardless if Whale #1 rally or single attacked. So this argument is null.

    Case 3:
    - Rally against another whale (Whale #2 and beyond)
    - For reference lets say Whale #1 and #2 both have 3mil T4's each
    - Reference #2 lets say Whale #1 will have max T4 rally (2 - 2.5mil T4s)
    - Whale #2 has 3mil T4's in his personal defense,  1mil reinforcements from allies,  300-600k from another garrison (lets also say all T4s to be consistent)
    - Whale #1 now has 2.5mil T4s in his rally against Whale #2 who has (4.3mil to 4.6mil T4s)
    Translate
    2020-3-2 22:44  Reply
  • Case 3 Summary:
    - Both whales will eat each other alive. You're not in the "Whale" category so this does not affect you at all.
    - Whales will have more fun fighting each other because the current way this is set up is you can only zero other whales only if a another whale is offline and unbubbled. BORING.
    Translate
    2020-3-2 22:44  Reply
  • bad logic man ... to zero whales u need 2-3 alliances... so when he gets favor, u set 3 full rallys on his ass and than each rally needs few rally speedups and than u hit the guy with 3 rallys on same second anywhere on map  and some solos if needed after the rallys and there u have the big bad wolf is no more, its a game of patiance and strategy...

    if u make it ur way than ur just making the game more in to mony advantage...
    and i dare any whale of any server to come and deal with me as solo atacks   
    once u understand the game u will think difrently
    Translate
    2020-3-3 05:26  Reply
  • Counterargument #1: Whale randoms out and waits out his 15 minutes of fervor, then bubbles.

    Counterargument #2: You argue my proposal makes the game favor players who spends money, however you are suggesting non-whale players (2-3 alliances' worth by the way) to use multiple rally speedups, which will be ridiculously expensive. In addition, you suggest these weaker alliances and players to coordinate their solo attacks (of mostly T3's) on a whale's impenetrable massive T4 wall? That won't work, sorry.

    You're contradicting your own arguments.

    Translate
    2020-3-3 06:11  Reply

 howas1337 Last edit in 2020-2-29 04:26:03

 Support

Report
Default Signature
Reply

Use magic Report

1

Threads

2

Posts

0

Credits

User

Rank: 1

Credits
0
Fooly Man
User
Posts:2
Joined 2019-11-17
Last Visited 2020-07-08
 Author| Post time 2020-2-29 09:24:30 | Show all posts
@howas I'm also a whale and I'd rather have this feature than a game where 1 whale kills a whole server without repercussions. It's boring.
Translate
Floor reply (2)
  • https://imgur.com/a/NMRihhR

    game knologe vs money...
    so game is perfectly balanced
    Translate
    2020-3-2 17:17  Reply
  • You're not showing us anything. Just troop numbers and power differences in order to fabricate a point you're trying to make. Show us troop type and/if there are any reinforcements from other players in that possible trap account.  
    Translate
    2020-3-2 22:26  Reply

 Fooly Man Last edit in 2020-2-29 09:24:30

 Support

Report
Default Signature
Reply

Use magic Report

0

Threads

1237

Posts

0

Credits

Team Lead

Rank: 7Rank: 7Rank: 7

Credits
0
pastdark
Team Lead
Posts:1237
Joined 2019-7-25
Last Visited 2020-10-25
Post time 2020-2-29 11:09:02 | Show all posts
Dear Fooly Man,

I'll put in your suggestion to the devs
Translate
Floor reply (0)

 pastdark Last edit in 2020-2-29 11:09:02

 Support

Report
Reply

Use magic Report

You have to log in before you can reply Login | Register Now

Points Rules

小黑屋|community.gtarcade.com

2021-12-7 17:05 GMT+8 , Processed in 0.081436 second(s), 41 queries .

Powered by Discuz! X3.2

© 2001-2013 Comsenz Inc.

To Top Return to the list