GuildWar - Bug?

angelcharmer

Hi there,

I think I have enough evidence to proof there is stil something wrong in guildwar.
I defeated everyone in the Gate, last fight I had 6 heroes standing, my last opponent 1.
Viewing the entire battle gave me the Victory. But the gate was given to the other guild!

This doesn't add up.

Translate

rassei

Hello,

Without seeing the battle my answer is this:
As you failed to kill the other player in 30 turns, the victory is automatically given to him. You only have to lose 1 battle to lose a building.  

Best Regards

Translate

angelcharmer

Huh? But my opponent failed to defeat me in 30 turns, so the victory should automatically be given to me. If I understand your post rassei.

I mean, why am I supposed to lose after 30 turns and not my opponent? I had all 6 heroes standing while my opponent only had 1 left.



But here is a video of the last turns, after which it shows Victory for me. >>click<<

Translate

tss86

As I know the player on the left is considered the attacker and the player on the right the defender. If the attacker can not beat the deffender in 30 rounds the defender wins.

Translate

rassei

Hello,

What tss86 said is correct. There was a discussion about adding more criteria for victory, but as that would be a major change in an old code which affects the entire game i don't think the devs will be comfortable with that.

Best Regards

Translate

angelcharmer

In GuildWar there is no defending or attacking team. Who's on the left or right should not be a deciding factor, because that seems to be random! The rules to win should be based on who wins the fight, and my video is clear on that.

I would appreciate it if you can pass this onto the defs rassei. Ragrdless of their comfort.

Translate