Raiders synthing

shane johnson

I was raided today after synthesising the chest... i went to collect it and poof it was gone.... Im sorry but my understanding of things is that once u synthesis something it is no longer what it was but something new..... Hence 4 shards become one chest....How then is it possable to be raided for a shard when the chest has already been synthensised?..... I dont know about anyone else but that just seems pretty screwy to me... How does the base ingrediant of a cookie get taken out after the cookie has already been made.... just a thought.....

Translate

drakenx

the timer shown when synthing is a count down or cool down.  You havn\'t made the chest until the timer counts down....use the protection when synthing to ensure yoou don\'t lose the shards

Translate

skyefire

               I was raided today after synthesising the chest... i went to collect it and poof it was gone....      shane johnson posted on 2014-03-07 17:41:11     

        @Kevin, if you read his post carefully, he stated that he had already synthesized the chest, and at some point between the chest being completed and him collecting it, the completed chest disappeared because someone raided a shard from him.

        @Shane,
        I agree this is screwy and bad implementation, as your logic tracks with the concept of synthing. And I don\'t understand it either, as I have have guild members say something to the same effect. I don\'t see any difference in creating a chest out of shards from creating the lv 40 or lv 60 armors (aside from the armor synthing being instantaneous), and how many people would get angry if other players could steal the armor shards we labor to collect from Erebus, if we had to wait for those shards to synthesize together.

Translate

christopher bowman

        Shards aren\'t used until the chest is collected. Please read the forum topic over it as I understood it clearly when it came out myself. And I know others did too. I know it doesn\'t state is specifically but it is implied if you look at it. As we all know nothing is completed until you claim it.

Translate

shane johnson

        You say nothing is completed till u claim it, yet if the chest wasnt completed there wouldnt be an option to claim it..... Since how can u claim something that isnt already made? As per my example..... You cant eat a cookie till its made, and should u try u only get a mouthfull of ingrediants that are nothing like the completed result... Therefor if i am able to claim a chest the implied concept is that the chest is already made, and  IF the chest is made and ready to be claimed. how then can a single ingrediant be removed from it, and make it no longer made?  The idea is that once u make something from other things you cant simply take out one ingrediant and turn it back to waht it once was.....its made, and therefor complete even if its not collected.
         If a tree falls in the woods, and no one is around to hear it. Does it make a sound?

Translate

wolfolk

if a moron is given a correct answer and he refusses to accept it is he more of a moron?

Translate

shane johnson

Reply 5# wolfolk
is an asshole opens is it not shit that spews forth? thank you for your ignorance....helpfull coments may be met with kinder replies....

Translate

daemonp

Reply 6# shane johnson
i know it really pissed me off, i have syth shard and already complete it, but someone stolen my shard andddddddd........ i cant claim my shard. we hope G M LOA will fix this .

Translate

christopher bowman

                                      You say nothing is completed till u claim it, yet if the chest wasnt completed there wouldnt be an option to claim it..... Since how can u claim something that isnt already made? As per my example..... You cant eat a cookie till its made, and should u try u only get a mouthfull of ingrediants that are nothing like the completed result... Therefor if i am able to claim a chest the implied concept is that the chest is already made, and  IF the chest is made and ready to be claimed. how then can a single ingrediant be removed from it, and make it no longer made?  The idea is that once u make something from other things you cant simply take out one ingrediant and turn it back to waht it once was.....its made, and therefor complete even if its not collected.       
                         If a tree falls in the woods, and no one is around to hear it. Does it make a sound?        
    shane johnson posted on 2014-03-08 15:34:51     

        Interesting example you give there... as you can\'t eat a cookie until it\'s collected... thanks for reconfirming it. And this is a game btw... that defies such things as simple logic. Don\'t argue semantics as you still lose in the end as you have voiced having happened here.

Translate