North America Forum

 Forgot password?
 立即注册
Search

Website Magerealm Suggestions
1298 Threads / 4865 Reply
Search   Favorites  

View: 670| Reply: 17

How to Improve Skirmish

[Copy link]

54

Threads

262

Posts

0

Credits

User

Rank: 1

Credits
0
damanto
User
Posts:262
Joined 2015-9-12
Last Visited 2015-12-09
Post time 2015-11-23 16:00:27 | Show all posts |Read mode
How to Improve Skirmish Reply:17| View:670

        Bugs:
        1) Disconnect issues. Many people are suffering from this.

        2) Hit Rating issue: It is quite annoying to miss 7-8 hit out of 10. Hit points from heroes; do not contribute to total hit points.

        Problems:
        1) Mounts: It is really really annoying to allow mounts in this event. Players should not be able to summon mounts in combat. There should be at least 5 sec cooldown and 2-3 channeling time. It is really annoying to chase people who are continuously pushing mount button. This is beyond absurdity. I do not know any game that has combat mounting in PVP. This is a really serious problem.

        2) Event is very one sided: I do not remember losing any skirmish out of my last 12-15 attempts. Game should give other players some chance. Maybe add 2-3 random buff that are really strong (25% attack, 25% hp etc. lasting 30 sec) appearing in random locations every two or three minute etc.
        Adding 20-25 bots is also another idea. Think about this: if you just hit level 70, you know that you are the weakest in the skirmish and cannot kill any opponent there. Then, why would you want to even participate in this event?
        Give weaker player some hope to power and enjoy. Otherwise, a weak player is waiting to be killed by a really strong player.
        Categorize Skirmish based on BR instead of level: Maybe allow only players with +/- 25% BR to go into the same skirmish..
        SSS tier Skirmish: 2700k BR- 3500k BR
SS tier Skirmish: 2000k BR- 2700k BR
S tier Skirmish: 1400k BR- 2000k BR
A tier Skirmish: 900k BR- 1400k BR
B tier Skirmish: 500k - 900k BR
C tier Skirmish: 200k - 500k BR

 damanto Last edit in 2015-11-23 16:00:27

 Support

Report
Default Signature
Reply

Use magic Report

26

Threads

692

Posts

0

Credits

User

Rank: 1

Credits
0
aiucard
User
Posts:692
Joined 2015-6-27
Last Visited 2016-04-21
Post time 2015-11-23 17:01:57 | Show all posts

How to Improve Skirmish

        tbh, I think rather than matching by BR, they should actually make it a guild event and remove friendly fire so you cant hurt your guild members. That way, even weaker players can enjoy better rewards at the end if the rewards are based on guild performance. This further eliminates the need to bother implementing a cross server guild war since skirmish would end up taking its place.;

        Agreed with the hit rating issue though...I think its especially relevant to TKs...I\'ve literally died 1v1 to a TK in skirmish who can barely survive 2 or 3 attacks from me in raiders, just cause I keep missing inside of skirmish...and its not like the stat boost from my heroes is bad either, all of my heroes are quite decently built and my raider especially. If hero hit stat was being added to us, then I\'m sure I wouldn\'t be having such trouble hitting people.;
Floor reply (1)
  • that would be a problem on S110 Killers would win every event there is if they changed it to that. half of the top 10 players are from killers, and the top 3 are all from Killers guild
    2015-12-4 17:36  Reply

 aiucard Last edit in 2015-11-23 17:01:57

 Support

Report
Default Signature
Reply Support Not support

Use magic Report

54

Threads

262

Posts

0

Credits

User

Rank: 1

Credits
0
damanto
User
Posts:262
Joined 2015-9-12
Last Visited 2015-12-09
 Author| Post time 2015-11-23 23:10:53 | Show all posts

How to Improve Skirmish

          ;;;;                        tbh, I think rather than matching by BR, they should actually make it a guild event and remove friendly fire so you cant hurt your guild members. That way, even weaker players can enjoy better rewards at the end if the rewards are based on guild performance. This further eliminates the need to bother implementing a cross server guild war since skirmish would end up taking its place.;       
       
                        Agreed with the hit rating issue though...I think its especially relevant to TKs...I\'ve literally died 1v1 to a TK in skirmish who can barely survive 2 or 3 attacks from me in raiders, just cause I keep missing inside of skirmish...and its not like the stat boost from my heroes is bad either, all of my heroes are quite decently built and my raider especially. If hero hit stat was being added to us, then I\'m sure I wouldn\'t be having such trouble hitting people.;       
;;; aiucard posted on 2015-11-23 04:01:57;;;;

;This will give more advantage to bigger guilds. If it is hard to balance at a single player, it will be impossible to balance at a guild level....
Floor reply (0)

 damanto Last edit in 2015-11-23 23:10:53

 Support

Report
Default Signature
Reply Support Not support

Use magic Report

54

Threads

262

Posts

0

Credits

User

Rank: 1

Credits
0
damanto
User
Posts:262
Joined 2015-9-12
Last Visited 2015-12-09
 Author| Post time 2015-11-24 01:11:51 | Show all posts

How to Improve Skirmish

        Skirmish is getting really annoy every day.;
        In-Combat Mounting should go away!!!!!;
        There is no other way. Has any of designers played any skirmish? What kind of logic do you have with in-combat mounting in Skirmish.;
Floor reply (0)

 damanto Last edit in 2015-11-24 01:11:51

 Support

Report
Default Signature
Reply Support Not support

Use magic Report

57

Threads

258

Posts

0

Credits

User

Rank: 1

Credits
0
blinkill
User
Posts:258
Joined 2015-7-9
Last Visited 2016-07-23
Post time 2015-11-24 03:59:05 | Show all posts

How to Improve Skirmish

Reply 3# damanto
        I don\'t think mounts are problem..
        Problem is unbalanced mode in the skirmish.
        btw skirmish is boring.. turn on auto and go drink a coffee..
Floor reply (0)

 blinkill Last edit in 2015-11-24 03:59:05

 Support

Report
Default Signature
Reply Support Not support

Use magic Report

54

Threads

262

Posts

0

Credits

User

Rank: 1

Credits
0
damanto
User
Posts:262
Joined 2015-9-12
Last Visited 2015-12-09
 Author| Post time 2015-11-24 04:08:13 | Show all posts

How to Improve Skirmish


          ;;;; Reply 3# damanto
                        I don\'t think mounts are problem..        
                        Problem is unbalanced mode in the skirmish.        
                        btw skirmish is boring.. turn on auto and go drink a coffee..        
;;; blinkill posted on 2015-11-23 14:59:05;;;;


        I do skirmish in manual mode every single time. You cannot win with automode even if you have 500k higher BR than others. You need to decide who to attack and who not to attack. You do not want to waste your time on unkillable opponents or an opponent that you can kill in 2 minutes. AI cannot make that decision for you.
        As someone who does all skirmish in manual mode, I DO think that mounts are a very big problem. Mounts make the skirmish ;a mosquito catching content rather than a PVP battle..
Floor reply (0)

 damanto Last edit in 2015-11-24 04:08:13

 Support

Report
Default Signature
Reply Support Not support

Use magic Report

21

Threads

143

Posts

0

Credits

User

Rank: 1

Credits
0
abwjuz3fxwpmefzi
User
Posts:143
Joined 2015-11-10
Last Visited 2015-12-31
Post time 2015-11-24 08:04:59 | Show all posts

How to Improve Skirmish

          ;;;;                          ;;;; Reply 3# damanto
                                        I don\'t think mounts are problem..                
                                        Problem is unbalanced mode in the skirmish.                
                                        btw skirmish is boring.. turn on auto and go drink a coffee..                
;;; blinkill posted on 2015-11-23 14:59:05;;;;        

       
                        I do skirmish in manual mode every single time. You cannot win with automode even if you have 500k higher BR than others. You need to decide who to attack and who not to attack.;You do not want to waste your time on unkillable opponents or an opponent that you can kill in 2 minutes. AI cannot make that decision for you.        
                        As someone who does all skirmish in manual mode, I DO think that mounts are a very big problem. Mounts make the skirmish ;a mosquito catching content rather than a PVP battle..       
;;; damanto posted on 2015-11-23 15:08:13;;;;


        Im guessing a lower BR ranked player took over your no.1 spot?
        no offense
Floor reply (0)

 abwjuz3fxwpmefzi Last edit in 2015-11-24 08:04:59

 Support

Report
Default Signature
Reply Support Not support

Use magic Report

54

Threads

262

Posts

0

Credits

User

Rank: 1

Credits
0
damanto
User
Posts:262
Joined 2015-9-12
Last Visited 2015-12-09
 Author| Post time 2015-11-24 08:34:41 | Show all posts

How to Improve Skirmish


          ;;;;                          ;;;;                                          ;;;; Reply 3# damanto
                                                        I don\'t think mounts are problem..                        
                                                        Problem is unbalanced mode in the skirmish.                        
                                                        btw skirmish is boring.. turn on auto and go drink a coffee..                        
;;; blinkill posted on 2015-11-23 14:59:05;;;;                

               
                                        I do skirmish in manual mode every single time. You cannot win with automode even if you have 500k higher BR than others. You need to decide who to attack and who not to attack.;You do not want to waste your time on unkillable opponents or an opponent that you can kill in 2 minutes. AI cannot make that decision for you.                
                                        As someone who does all skirmish in manual mode, I DO think that mounts are a very big problem. Mounts make the skirmish ;a mosquito catching content rather than a PVP battle..               
;;; damanto posted on 2015-11-23 15:08:13;;;;        

       
                        Im guessing a lower BR ranked player took over your no.1 spot?       
                        no offense       
;;; abwjuz3fxwpmefzi@facebook.com posted on 2015-11-23 19:04:59;;;;

        Not really.. As I said, I won last 12-15 skirmish that I played every single time. I lost only one skirmish so far, which I had to go automode with hotel internet.. I am mature enough to admit that I win skirmish every single time I play it.
        I am stating a problem in the game. It is not because I am losing or lost a game. I am winning and still stating that there is a problem with the skirmish mechanics.
        No other PVP allows ability to instant mount during in combat. It is fine to have mount but not fine to be able one-click mount and escape from combat. This does not happen in any game that is decent. It is totally stuupid idea. I have played at least 30 different MMO. Have not seen this in any single pvp.
       

        You should understand that  I am bored of winning every time. Make skirmish more challenging.

        I stated that skirmish should give some more chance to lower BR people.

        I do not enjoy catching flies in skirmish. Make weak BR players stronger for 30 sec with huge random buff. I prefer that over just chasing ride/spammers.

Floor reply (0)

 damanto Last edit in 2015-11-24 08:34:41

 Support

Report
Default Signature
Reply Support Not support

Use magic Report

22

Threads

142

Posts

0

Credits

User

Rank: 1

Credits
0
shinja2468
User
Posts:142
Joined 2015-8-10
Last Visited 2017-11-21
Post time 2015-11-24 16:05:36 | Show all posts

How to Improve Skirmish

                                Categorize Skirmish based on BR instead of level: Maybe allow only players with +/- 25% BR to go into the same skirmish..       
                        SSS tier Skirmish: 2700k BR- 3500k BR
SS tier Skirmish: 2000k BR- 2700k BR
S tier Skirmish: 1400k BR- 2000k BR
A tier Skirmish: 900k BR- 1400k BR
B tier Skirmish: 500k - 900k BR
C tier Skirmish: 200k - 500k BR       
;;; damanto posted on 2015-11-23 03:00:27;;;;

The issue with that is the fact that skirmish is only linked to your 10 related server like 65 to 75 are linked(random number) and this skirmish tier would actually be bad because like me the strongest opponent that I can face have 2600k BR and I have 3000k... So I would be alone in my skirmish with no one to kill...
Floor reply (0)

 shinja2468 Last edit in 2015-11-24 16:05:36

 Support

Report
Default Signature
Reply Support Not support

Use magic Report

26

Threads

692

Posts

0

Credits

User

Rank: 1

Credits
0
aiucard
User
Posts:692
Joined 2015-6-27
Last Visited 2016-04-21
Post time 2015-11-25 21:12:12 | Show all posts

How to Improve Skirmish

Reply 2# damanto
They haven\'t even balanced classes yet, so I think an event balancing is a bit too much to hope for, thus I suggested that. If rewards are based on guild performance, not individual performance, people can clump up into the few strongest guilds (I think only S1 has enough players to make this impossible) since most servers don\'t have a huge amount of actives. Clump up into groups, turn skirmish into a CS guild war of sorts, kills several birds with 1 stone. Weaker players get better rewards due to guild overall performance being better than their individual. The devs don\'t need to design an entirely different CS guild war event. Skirmish will finally become an actual guild event. Last but not least, ofc, this means no more friendly fire in skirmish between guildmates
Floor reply (0)

 aiucard Last edit in 2015-11-25 21:12:12

 Support

Report
Default Signature
Reply Support Not support

Use magic Report

You have to log in before you can reply Login | Register Now

Points Rules

小黑屋|community.gtarcade.com

2017-12-15 08:53 GMT+8 , Processed in 0.057977 second(s), 51 queries .

Powered by Discuz! X3.2

© 2001-2013 Comsenz Inc.

To Top Return to the list